A ₹53-Crore GST Demand Just Collapsed Because the Taxman Treated a Circular’s “Option” as an Order — the Supreme Court Disagreed
For a solar EPC contractor, the years 1 July 2017 to 31 December 2018 should have been straightforward: GST had just arrived, solar power generating systems were taxed under their own entry, and the law said what it said. Then, in October 2021, the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs issued Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST — nearly three years after the fact — offering taxpayers an option to split their pre-2019 contract values 70:30 between goods and services for GST purposes, the same formula the law would only make mandatory from 1 January 2019 onward under Notification No. 24/2018-Central Tax (Rate).
Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd. didn’t take up that option for its 2017–18 EPC contracts. The GST department decided it should have — and went further, invoking Section 74 of the CGST Act to allege fraud and wilful suppression, which let it reach back under the extended limitation period. By the time the Joint Commissioner, Thane and the Superintendent, Range V, Santacruz, Mumbai were done, the company faced a combined CGST and SGST demand, with penalty, of ₹53,35,80,964.
STERLING AND WILSON v. UNION OF INDIA — KEY POINTS
₹53.36-crore GST demand set aside in full
Supreme Court of India — 2026 INSC 1222, decided 16 November 2026
Bench: Sanjay Kumar, J. (author) & Sanjeev Sachdeva, J. • SLP (C) No. 23844 of 2025 • 70:30 solar-EPC valuation ratio held optional, not mandatory, for pre-1 Jan 2019 supplies • Section 74 extended limitation held unavailable
Sidebar: the arithmetic behind that figure is itself instructive — ₹13,33,95,241 in CGST plus an equal penalty (₹26,67,90,482 combined), mirrored by an identical SGST-side demand, is what happens when a department applies a formula retroactively across an entire multi-year contract book rather than testing it transaction by transaction.
On 16 November 2026, the Supreme Court set the whole demand aside. In M/s. Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. (2026 INSC 1222, arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 23844 of 2025), a Bench of Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva held that the department had converted a taxpayer-facing concession into a retrospective mandate — and had no basis to do either.
Why It Matters
The Court’s reasoning rests on three distinct findings, each independently fatal to the department’s case:
- The 70:30 ratio was never the law before 1 January 2019. It originates in Notification No. 24/2018-Central Tax (Rate), dated 31 December 2018, which took effect only from 1 January 2019. For the 1 July 2017–31 December 2018 window, no such statutory split existed.
- Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST gave taxpayers a choice, not a command. The 2021 circular let assessees elect to apply the 70:30 ratio to their pre-2019 supplies if they wished — a relief measure, not a retrospective extension of the 2019 notification. The Court held there was “no mandate” requiring every pre-2019 taxpayer to have used that ratio.
- Section 74 could not apply to a period before the rule the department says was violated even existed. Since the 70:30 requirement itself only began on 1 January 2019, the question of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression in not following it for an earlier period “does not even arise.” The extended limitation period under Section 74 was therefore never properly available.
The Court separately noted that Notification No. 8/2021 had replaced the tariff entry “solar power generating system” with “solar power generator” — a terminological change the department could not use to reach backward either.
Who Is Affected
Any solar EPC/turnkey contractor, or any business that executed composite supply-and-install contracts for solar power generating systems between July 2017 and December 2018 and has an open assessment, demand, or ongoing litigation built on an assumed 70:30 split for that period. The ruling is squarely about that narrow window — contracts from 1 January 2019 onward are unaffected, since the 70:30 ratio genuinely is the applicable rule from that date.
Key Takeaways
- The 70:30 goods-to-services valuation split for solar power generating systems became law only from 1 January 2019 (Notification No. 24/2018-Central Tax (Rate)).
- Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST (6 October 2021) gave taxpayers the option — not an obligation — to apply that ratio to their 1 July 2017–31 December 2018 supplies as well.
- Section 74’s fraud/extended-limitation ground cannot be invoked for not applying a rule to a period before that rule existed.
- The Supreme Court set aside the entire ₹53,35,80,964 CGST+SGST+penalty demand against Sterling and Wilson on these grounds.
Practical Implications
- A pending demand for the pre-2019 period that assumes the 70:30 ratio was mandatory, rather than elective, is now vulnerable on the same ground Sterling and Wilson succeeded on.
- A Section 74 invocation tied solely to not having applied the 70:30 ratio before 1 January 2019 has no legal foundation after this ruling — taxpayers facing such notices have a direct, on-point Supreme Court precedent to cite.
- Taxpayers who did voluntarily elect the 70:30 ratio under the 2021 circular for their own pre-2019 supplies are not disturbed by this ruling — it confirms that election was optional, not that it was wrong to make.
Action Checklist
- Identify any open assessment, show-cause notice, or appeal involving GST on solar EPC/SPG contracts for the 1 July 2017–31 December 2018 period.
- Check whether the demand relies on treating the 70:30 ratio as mandatory, rather than elective, for that period — if so, cite Sterling and Wilson (2026 INSC 1222) directly.
- Where Section 74 has been invoked for this period on this basis alone, challenge the extended-limitation ground specifically, using the Court’s “does not even arise” finding.
- Confirm the contract period before relying on this ruling — it does not assist disputes concerning supplies made on or after 1 January 2019.
Relevant Sections & Notifications
Section 74, CGST Act, 2017 (fraud/wilful misstatement; extended limitation). Notification No. 24/2018-Central Tax (Rate), dated 31 December 2018 (effective 1 January 2019) — 70:30 deemed valuation for solar power generating systems. Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST, dated 6 October 2021 — elective 70:30 ratio for 1 July 2017–31 December 2018 supplies. Notification No. 8/2021 — tariff-entry terminology change (“solar power generating system” → “solar power generator”).
FAQs
Does this ruling mean solar EPC contracts never attract GST on a 70:30 split? No — from 1 January 2019 onward, the 70:30 ratio is the statutory position. The ruling concerns only the earlier, pre-2019 period, where the ratio was an option, not a rule.
Can a taxpayer who already paid tax on the 70:30 basis for the pre-2019 period now claim it was wrong to do so? The ruling doesn’t say applying the 70:30 ratio for that period was incorrect — only that it wasn’t mandatory. A taxpayer who elected it under the 2021 circular made a valid choice; this ruling does not unwind that.
Is this judgment specific to Sterling and Wilson, or does it have wider precedent value? It is a Supreme Court ruling interpreting the scope of a CBIC circular and a CGST Act provision — the legal reasoning applies to any similarly-placed taxpayer, not merely to this one company’s facts.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Readers should consult a qualified professional for advice specific to their facts. The judgment’s citation, bench, dates, statutory references and the ₹53,35,80,964 demand figure were verified directly from the Supreme Court’s judgment text (2026 INSC 1222) and independently cross-checked against Taxscan’s law report (2026 TAXSCAN (SC) 274); a conflicting, uncorroborated figure appearing in one other secondary outlet was not relied upon. Prepared by Finoscape Editorial Team — hello@finoscape.com.